|
INSTALLMENT AGREEMENTS AND OTHER OPTIONS
By: Robert E. McKenzie
3-4 PAYMENT AGREEMENTS
3-4.10 Prior to the passage of the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, effective
November 10, 1989, there was no specific statutory authority for allowing a
taxpayer to make installment payments.2 The Code now specifically
authorizes the Service to grant installment payment plans. [IRC § 6159) Even
before passage of this provision the IRS granted thousands of payment agreements
per year. Payment agreements are allowed on any type of tax including employment
taxes. It is much more difficult to secure a payment agreement for employment
taxes than income taxes.
Guaranteed Availability of Installment Agreements
3-4.13 The Internal Revenue Service Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998
requires the Secretary to grant an installment agreement, at the taxpayer's
option, if:
[Act § 3467; IRC § 6159)
Prior Administrative Rights
3-4.17 Prior to the passage of the Internal Revenue Service
Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998, IRM 5331.31(now obsolete) authorized IRS
employees to grant installment payment agreements of up to three years to
taxpayers who owe individual income taxes of less than $10,000. Internal Revenue
Service Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 § 3467 imposes a specific
statutory requirement that the Internal Revenue Service grant an installment
agreement to taxpayers who owe less than $10,000 of individual income taxes
including penalties and interest. Any agreement may be defaulted if the taxpayer
fails to meet any subsequent tax obligations during the pendency of the
installment agreement. The provision creates statutory rights, when in the past
installment agreements for small liabilities were merely policy.
Modifications of Installment Agreements
3-4.25 The Taxpayer Bill of Rights 2 requires the IRS to give a notice
of proposed action not later than thirty days prior to the proposed date before
termination or modification of an installment agreement. The IRS is also
required to include an explanation as to why the agreement is being modified or
terminated. This provision become effective January 20,1997. Prior to the
effective date the Internal Revenue Service is required to establish procedures
for an independent administrative review of terminations of installment
agreements. [IRC § 6159(b)]
Collection Information Statements
3-4.30 For larger dollar liabilities (income tax liabilities in excess
of $25,000) the starting point for analysis is the Service's Collection
Information Statement (CIS). The preparation of this document, more often than
not, determines which way the Service will proceed with its collection activity.
Copies of the CIS's currently used by the Service for individuals and for
businesses are provided in the appendices at the end of this chapter. The IRS
will not give extended payment plans on unpaid tax liabilities unless a CIS has
been submitted by the taxpayer.
3-5 COLLECTION INFORMATION STATEMENTS
3-5.10 The IRS utilizes three basic types of Collection Information Statements (CIS's). The Form 433-A and Form 433-F are secured from individuals. The
Form 433-B is secured from businesses. If the taxpayer is self employed the
Service will normally require both a 433-A and 433-B.
3-6 FORM 433-A
3-6.10 Form 433-A is utilized by Revenue Officers to gather financial data from taxpayers. The first 2 pages are almost entirely dedicated to gathering Levy sources. If your client has any illnesses, disclose them in the Other Information section on page 3. The Service will consider bad health to be a basis for granting an extension. Page 6 of the Form is a balance sheet. The IRS will normally demand immediate payment if the 433-A indicates substantial equity on the balance sheet.
Amount of Payments
3-6.20 Page 6 is a monthly income and expense analysis. The IRS will
not grant a Payment Plan for less than the difference between income and claimed
expenses. The IRS utilizes information from the Bureau of Labor Statistics to
establish allowable expenses for certain items like transportation, food,
clothing and housing. Those allowable expenses might be less that the amount
actually being paid by the taxpayer. [See Section 3-9].
3-7 F0RM 433-F
3-7.10 Form 433-F is utilized by Collection Support Staff and ACS to
gather financial data from individuals with smaller tax liabilities. It is not
normally used by Revenue Officers.
3-7.20 The IRS will normally require the taxpayer to pay an
installment equal to his or her net income less "reasonable" expenses.
The individuals assigned to negotiate payment agreements in CSS and ACS are not
well trained in financial analysis. Many of the author's clients who have
negotiated on their own behalf have been required to hire a representative
because of unreasonable payment demands after submission of a 433-F.
3-8 F0RM 433-B
3-8.10 The IRS utilizes Form 433-B to gather information from
businesses. Page 1, Section 3, requests that your client disclose each of its
accounts receivable. The author believes that such a disclosure is foolhardy at
the initial negotiating session. If disclosure is made and the negotiations
fail, the IRS may levy your client's accounts receivable, thereby destroying its
business.
Cash Flow Statement
3-8.30 Page 5 is the determinative part of Form 433-B.
Note: Page 5 is a cash flow statement, not a profit and loss
statement. The IRS will seldom grant a payment plan if the client indicates a
large positive cash flow. The IRS believes such businesses should secure a
private loan. On the other hand, the Service will seldom grant a payment plan to
a company with a negative cash flow which does not have excess funds to make
payments to the IRS. Therefore, a taxpayer with a small positive cash flow has
the best chance of securing a payment agreement. The size of the liability is a
significant factor in the decision to grant or deny a payment agreement.
3-9 CRITERIA FOR GRANTING AN INSTALLMENT AGREEMENT
3-9.10 The Collection Division employee is trained to analyze the
Collection Information Statement (CIS) for ways to liquidate the delinquent
account:
If a taxpayer has cash equal to or in excess of the tax liability, the IRS
will demand immediate payment.
Assets are reviewed to identify those which may be pledged or readily
converted to cash such as stocks, bonds, loan value of life insurance policies,
equity in real estate, etc.
The Collection Division employee will consider the taxpayer's ability to make
an unsecured loan based upon the taxpayer's earning potential.
If the taxpayer has available credit on a bank charge card, the IRS may
demand that the taxpayer draw on the full cash credit line and submit the
proceeds to the Service.
If there appears to be no borrowing or liquidation ability, the Service may
ask the taxpayer to defer payment of other debts in order to pay the tax
liability as a first priority.
Completion of Page 4 of CIS
3-9.20 When all else fails, and an examination of the Collection
Information Statement has given no obvious solution for liquidating the
liability, the IRS employee will complete the income and expense analysis
portion of the Collection Information Statement for the purpose of determining
the maximum installment amount the taxpayer can pay. The IRS will review the
claimed expenses of the taxpayer in relation to allowable expenses as determined
by the IRS (see Section 3-9.30 et seq. for further discussion).
Allowable Expenses
3-9.30 As of August 29,1995, the Internal Revenue Service adopted new
policies with respect to expenses which would be allowed for taxpayers on Forms
433-A and 433-F. The new allowable expenses created two categories: Necessary
Expenses and Conditional Expenses. Taxpayers who establish necessary expenses
based on national and local standards are allowed these expenses for
consideration of any installment agreement or Offer in Compromise. Conditional
expenses would be those expenses that the IRS did not consider to meet the
necessary tests, but which it would allow if the taxpayer can pay the
outstanding taxes with an installment agreement within the three years. If the
taxpayer could not pay within three years, she would be allowed one year to
adjust her conditional expenses.
Necessary Expenses
3-9.40 The new IRS procedures provide that a necessary expense will be
allowable if it meets the necessary expense test: "Provide for a taxpayer's
and his or her family's health and welfare and/or the production of
income." The Internal Revenue Service requires that the expense must be
reasonable. The IRS believes that the total necessary expenses establish the
minimum a taxpayer and family need to live. The IRS has created three necessary
expense categories:
Conditional Expenses
3-9.50 The second category of expenses which the IRS may choose to
allow are those which do not meet the IRS Necessary Expense Test. However,
conditional expenses are allowable if the taxpayer has the ability to pay the
tax liability, including projected accruals, within five years. The requirements
for conditional expenses are as follows:
Five-Year Rule. This rule establishes a time limit for any expense
determined to be excessive, necessary, and/or conditional expenses. They will be
allowed if the tax liability, including projected accruals, can be paid in full
within five years.
Expenses Which Will Not Require Substantiation
3-9.60 The IRS will no longer require substantiation of those expenses specified in the national standards. The IRS will allow the total national standards amount for the taxpayer's income level. Taxpayers making more than the highest income level shown in the national standards will be limited to the maximum amount allowed by the national standards unless they can substantiate and justify a larger amount. [IRM 5.15.1.3] The manner in which the taxpayer chooses to spend the national standards is up to the taxpayer. For example, the IRS manual specifies that the taxpayer could allocate less for clothing and spend more for entertainment; or more for food and less for clothing. If the taxpayer spends more than the total amount allowed by the national standards, the taxpayer will be required to justify that expense. For example, a taxpayer with special dietary needs will be required to establish the justification for additional food expense. In summary, if the taxpayer claims more than the national standards, she will be required to submit substantiation and justification, but if she claims an amount equal to the national standards, no substantiation will be required by the Internal Revenue Service.
Housing Expense
3-9.70 When applying the local housing standards the IRS employee is
allowed to consider other factors which might justify an expense in excess of
the local housing standard. For example, the IRS employee can consider the
following factors:
Transportation
3-9.80 The transportation amount established in the IRS Tables set the
standards for amounts to be allowed for car purchase and lease, repairs,
maintenance and fuel. The Internal Revenue Service takes the position that in
some metropolitan areas public transportation would be an appropriate means for
transportation to and from work for the taxpayer and therefore, it could choose
to disallow an automobile as a personal convenience for the taxpayer.
Necessary Expenses (Other)
3-9.90 The Internal Revenue Service has set forth the following
standards for Other Necessary Expenses:
| Expense Item | Expense is Necessary if: | Notes/Tips |
| Accounting and legal fees. | Representation before the Service is needed or meets the necessary expense tests. Amount must be reasonable. | Disallow any other accounting or legal fees. Disallow costs not related to solving current liability. |
| Charitable contributions (Donations to tax exempt organizations) | If it is a condition of employment or meets the necessary expense tests. Example: A minister is required to tithe according to his employment contract. | Disallow any other charitable contributions that are not considered necessary. Example: Review the employment contract. |
| Child Care(Baby-sitting, day care, nursery and preschool) | It meets the necessary expense test. Only reasonable amounts are allowed. | Cost of child care can vary greatly. Do not allow unusually large child care expense if more reasonable alternatives are available. Consider the age of the child and if both parents work. |
| Court-Ordered Payments(Alimony, child support, including orders made by the state, and other court ordered payments) | If court ordered and being paid, they are allowable. If payments are not being made, do not allow the expense. Child support payments for natural children or legally adopted dependents may be allowed. | Review the court order. |
| Dependent Care(For the care of the elderly, invalid, or handicapped.) | If there is no alternative to the taxpayer paying the expense. | |
| Education | It is required for a physically or mentally challenged child and no public education providing similar services is available. Also allowed only for the taxpayer and only if required as condition of employment. | Example: An attorney must take so many education credits each year or they will not be accredited and could eventually lose their license to practice before the State Bar. A teacher could lose their position or in some States their pay is commensurate with their education credits. |
| Health Care | Required for the health and welfare of the family. Elective surgery would not be allowed such as plastic surgery or elective dental work. The taxpayer must provide proof of excessive out of pocket medical expenses. | To determine monthly expenses, the total out of pocket expenses would be divided by 12. The Schedule A may also be used to determine the yearly expense. Ensure that the amount used is out of pocket after insurance claims are paid. Substantiate that payments are being made. |
| Involuntary Deductions | If it is a requirement of the job; i.e. union dues, uniforms, work shoes. | To determine monthly expenses, the total out of pocket expenses would be divided by 12. |
| Life Insurance | If it is a term policy on the life of the taxpayer only. | If there are whole life policies, these should be reviewed as an asset for borrowing against or liquidating. Life insurance used as an investment is not a necessary expense. |
| Secured or legally perfected debts | If it meets the necessary expense test. | Taxpayer must substantiate that the payments are being made. |
| Unsecured Debts | If the taxpayer substantiates and justifies the expense, the minimum payment may be allowed. The necessary expense test of health and welfare and/or production of income must be met. Except for payments required for the production of income, payments on unsecured debts will not be allowed if the tax liability, including projected accruals, can be paid in full within 90 days. | Examples of unsecured debts which may be necessary expenses include: Payments required for the production of income such as payments to suppliers and payments on lines of credit needed for business and payment of debts incurred in order to pay a federal tax liability. |
| Taxes | It is for current federal, FICA, Medicare, state and local taxes. | Current taxes are allowed regardless of whether the taxpayer made them in the past or not. Delinquent state and local taxes are allowable depending on the priority of the FTL and/or Service agreement with the state and local taxing agencies. |
| Optional Telephones and Telephone Services (Cell phone, pager, Call waiting, caller identification or long distance) | It must meet the necessary expense test. | |
| Student Loans | If it is secured by the federal government and only for the taxpayer's education. | Taxpayer must substantiate that the payments are being made. |
| Internet Provider/E-mail | If it meets the necessary expense test - generally for production of income. | |
| Repayment of loans made for payment of Federal Taxes | If the loan is secured by the taxpayer's assets when those assets are of reasonable value and are necessary to provide for the health and welfare of the family. |
Excessive Necessary and Conditional Expenses Incurred after
Assessment of Tax Liability
3-9.110 The Internal Revenue Service takes the position that it will
not apply the five year rule to any new conditional expense or excessive
necessary expense which occurs after the assessment of a tax liability. The
Internal Revenue Service employees are instructed that in such instances
consideration of enforcement against the post assessment assets or not allowing
the expenses in an installment agreement may be appropriate. The Internal
Revenue Service employee also has the authority, however, to make exceptions to
the five year rule. In unusual situations the Service can choose to allow
conditional expenses even if the liability, including projected accruals, cannot
be paid within three years. The employee is required to fully explain the basis
for such a decision and all expenses must be fully substantiated in all
instances. Such agreements can only be granted with the approval with the
employee's manager. As this new policy is being applied, very few IRS employees
have deemed to exercise the authority granted by the authority to vary from the
three year rule.
Applications of the Standards
3-9.115 Allowable Expense Standards are applied in three different
manners depending on whether the taxpayer can pay in less than five years, more
than five years or propounds an Offer in Compromise. If the taxpayer can pay in
less than three years, he is allowed National Standards, Regional Standards,
Local Standards, expenses necessary for production of income or health and
welfare to the taxpayer and Conditional Expenses. If the taxpayer needs more
than three years to pay, she is only allowed one year of Conditional Standards.
If the taxpayer propounds an Offer in Compromise, the Service will not allow
conditional expenses in any event.
Harsh Results of IRS Policies
3-9.120 As a result of the allowable expense standards, some taxpayers will be forced to make heart-wrenching decisions. For example, the taxpayer paying for a child's private school or university education will be told by the IRS that they have one year to change this expense because in one year the entire amount paid for tuition will be considered to be available for payments to the Internal Revenue Service. The taxpayer will then face the choice of removing his child from a university, for example, to allow payment of his tax debt, or removing his child from a private school or parochial school in order to pay his tax debt. It should be noted, however, that if at the end of the first year the taxpayer has not modified or eliminated an excessive necessary or not allowable conditional expense, an IRS employee can choose to grant additional time in unusual circumstances. Once again, any variance from the IRS standards must be approved by a Supervisor. Most IRS employees will not vary from the IRS standards without aggressive advocacy by the representative.
3-11 SMALL DOLLAR CASES
3-11.10 In small dollar income tax cases (less than $25,000
aggregate), taxpayers may be granted installment agreements by mail or telephone
for extended periods up to 60 months. [IRC § 6159] [IRM 4.20.4.2] For such low
dollar installment agreements, the Internal Revenue does not require a
Collection Information Statement. A payment plan of this type may be requested
by submitting a Form 9465 with the taxpayer's income tax return. The payment
arrangement may also be requested by writing to the Service Center during Notice
Status (i.e., 501, 502) to receive a payment plan. This written correspondence
may be accompanied by the Form 9465. The small dollar income tax agreements may
also be requested through the Automated Collection System (ACS) or Collection
Support Staff (CSS). Small dollar income tax cases which are assigned to a
Revenue Officer in TDA status may also be granted such plans without submission
of a collection information statement.
60-Month Agreements
3-11.20 On individual income taxes and out-of-business sole
proprietors of less than $25,000, the IRS is required to grant payment plans of
up to 60 months without requiring a CIS. These agreements can be secured by
telephone, in person or by correspondence. Revenue Officers, ACS, Collection
Support Staff and Service Center Personnel may grant such agreements. The
taxpayer must supply her bank account and place of employment. If the taxpayer
or his representative personally appear before the IRS, a written payment
agreement must be signed. If the payment agreement is secured by phone or via
correspondence, the Internal Revenue Service authorizes its employees to prepare
a payment agreement and note that the taxpayer agreement was secured by phone
and, therefore, there is no requirement for the taxpayer's signature. [IRM
4.20.4] The small dollar payment agreements are not granted for trust fund or
business taxes.
3-12 SHORT TERM EXTENSIONS
3-12.10 The Internal Revenue Manual grants authority to allow short
term extensions on larger dollar income taxes. Extensions to pay may be granted
to taxpayers whose accounts are not in TDA status regardless of the amount due.
This is not an installment agreement; it is simply an extension of time given
the taxpayer to make full payment of the liability. Extremely large business
taxpayers may only be granted extensions of up to 30 days; all other taxpayers
may be granted extensions of up to 120 days. The extensions may be granted in
person, by telephone or by correspondence. Since this is not an installment
agreement, no Form is required. If the taxpayer insists on a written
documentation of an extension of time to pay, the IRS will give him a Form 433-D
Installment Agreement. For extensions in excess of 60 days, a written
installment agreement is required.
3-13 VARIATIONS ON INSTALLMENT AGREEMENTS
3-13.10 IRS employees are allowed by their Internal Revenue
Manual to offer a payroll deduction option to a taxpayer being granted an
installment agreement. [IRM5.14.10].
Withholding by Employer
3-13.20 The Service's manual provides for installment payments to be
sent directly to the Service from the taxpayer's employer if and when the
employer agrees. With some clients, this may be the only way to ensure that
agreed-upon payments are made. Some employers balk at executing such agreements
for the Service because of the additional bookkeeping required.
Bargaining Tactics
3-13.30 For a client who has defaulted on previous payment agreements,
and/or who has suffered a Notice of Levy on his or her wages, the Payroll
Deduction Agreement gives the IRS the assurances it may need to grant or
reinstate a payment plan.
Direct Debit Installment Agreements
3-13.40 IRS employees may also grant Direct Debit Installment
Agreements (DDIA's) where payments are automatically debited from a taxpayer's
bank account for the agreed upon amount. The bank may transfer the payment via
electronic funds transfer to the IRS. The taxpayer will be required to sign a
Direct Debit Installment Agreement, Form 433-G. There will be a default if the
client has insufficient funds in the account on the debit date. The author
utilizes this method only when the IRS refuses to grant an agreement without a
DDIA.
3-14 TO 3-18 PARAGRAPHS INTENTIONALLY OMITTED
3-19 MODIFICATION AND TERMINATION OF PAYMENT AGREEMENTS
3-19.10 Prior to the passage of the Taxpayer Bill of Rights the IRS
took the position that it could revoke a payment agreement at will. An
installment agreement is now binding upon the IRS and may only be revoked or
modified for cause. [IRC § 6159(b)] The Service may alter, modify or terminate
an agreement for the following reasons:
3-20 TAXPAYER ASSISTANCE ORDERS
3-20.10 The taxpayer has the right to apply for assistance from the
Taxpayer Advocate if he or she is suffering or is about to suffer significant
hardship. Taxpayers have the statutory right to appeal unreasonable decisions by
collection officers. If your request for an agreement is unreasonably denied,
you may request a Taxpayer Assistance Order (TAO) which may require collection
personnel to release property levied upon or to cease any actions or refrain
from any action with respect to the taxpayer. [IRC § 7811(b)] A request is
initiated by filing Form 911 with the Taxpayer Advocate. The mere existence of
these rights tends to mitigate the unreasonableness of some collection
personnel. Do not continually threaten to appeal a TAO, but beware of your
rights. You must establish that the collection actions will cause your client
significant hardship to receive a Taxpayer Assistance Order.
Taxpayer Assistance Orders
3-20.20 The Internal Revenue Service Restructuring and Reform Act of
1998 expanded the definition of "significant hardship" by including
the following circumstances:
Nonexclusive
3-20.30 The list is not intended to be exclusive. A TAO may also be
issued in any case which the taxpayer meets other requirements that will be
spelled out in regulations. [IRC § 7811 (a)(1 )(B)] The ranks are to be based
in consideration of equity. If the Internal Revenue Service has failed to follow
published guidance, including the Internal Revenue Manual, the Taxpayer Advocate
is required to construe the facts taken into account in a manner most favorable
to the taxpayer. [Conf Rept 1 05-599(Pub L 105-206) p216]
3-20.35 TBR2 expanded the authority of the Taxpayer Advocate to issue
taxpayer assistance orders. The Taxpayer Advocate may now "order the IRS to
take any action as permitted by law" as opposed to simply ordering an IRS
employee "to cease any action."A taxpayer assistance order may no
longer be revoked by a District Director. That authority now rests solely with
the Commissioner of Internal Revenue Service or the Deputy Commissioner and only
if a written explanation listing the reasons for modification is provided to the
Taxpayer Advocate (Problem Resolution Officer). [IRC § 7802(d)(2)]
Extension of Statute of Limitations
3-20.40 The submission of a Form 911 extends the statute of
limitations for the duration of the time the matter is under consideration. The
statute begins to run again on the date the Taxpayer Advocate Office makes a
determination on the application. [IRC § 7811(c)]
3-21 CURRENTLY NOT COLLECTIBLE ACCOUNTS
3-21.10 Despite the Internal Revenue Service's powerful collection
tools, it is not able to collect all of its accounts receivable. It therefore
must report some accounts as currently not collectible. The Service's percentage
of uncollectible accounts is, however, significantly less than that of private
industry. The Service has a sophisticated computer-monitored system for
following up on those accounts that are reported currently not collectible. The
authority to declare accounts uncollectible is delegated to Revenue Officers,
CSS and/or ACS depending on the amount due.
Release of Levy When Amount Is Uncollectible
3-21.20 The Internal Revenue Service Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 requires the IRS to immediately release a wage levy upon agreement with the taxpayer that the tax is not collectible, effective for levies imposed after December 31,1999. [Act § 3432; IRC § 6342(e)]
3-22 BASIS FOR REPORTING ACCOUNTS UNCOLLECTIBLE
3-22.10 Situations under which the Internal Revenue Service may report
an account as currently not collectible are:
What constitutes "undue hardship" is strictly construed by the
Service. What many of us would view as "undue hardship" the Service
officially characterizes as "mere inconvenience." Revenue Officers
prepare a Form 53 when they report an account uncollectible. In IRS jargon,
Revenue Officers say they "53" an account when they report it
uncollectible.
03/03/2007